Ethan Mollick:隐藏思考过程让人更难参与 AI 工作
Claude 和 ChatGPT 不再提供详细的思考过程摘要(可能既是为了防止蒸馏,也是出于用户体验考虑),这让人在流程中参与变得困难。它推动我们走向自动化,而不是增强人的能力,因为现在更难在 AI 工作尚未完成时介入并提出意见。
我知道,这是因为思考过程变得太长,也包含太多专有信息。但几乎把它们完全隐藏起来、让 AI 只管施展“魔法”的解决办法,让我觉得缺乏想象力,也是在走向默认把人从中间环节移除的模式。这值得我们努力去挑战。
对照原文
The end of detailed summarized thinking traces for Claude and ChatGPT (likely both anti-distillation & for UX) has made being a human in the loop challenging. It pushes us towards automation, rather than augmentation, as it has become much harder to weigh in on in-process AI work
I realize this is because thinking traces have gotten too long (and too proprietary) but the solution of hiding them almost entirely so the AI just does "magic" feels like a failure of imagination and a move towards a default of disintermediation that is worth effort challenging.